Dearest Oakland,
It's with a heavy heart that I write this letter to bid you farewell. I'm leaving you. It was not an easy decision to make. You were my first love, the first city where I really felt I belonged. When I met you I was fresh-faced college freshman. Freshwoman, actually, in the lingo of Mills College, the women's liberal arts college that brought us together. Back then, you were like an older, mature, experienced lover. Not like the boys I dated back in high school. You had dark alleys that no girl should ever tread alone, but you also had wonderfully deep and lush trails nestled in the hills where a girl can ride her mountain bike and daydream. You had some serious social and emotional issues but you also had that urbane, diverse, sexy and slightly dangerous exterior that drew in naive young girls like me by the busloads.
When I graduated from college and our initial courtship ended, I left for what I thought were greener pastures. But I came running back to you, fleeing the safe suburb and white-bread homogeneousness that I was too young to resign myself to. I craved excitement, activism, and the ridiculous high cost of living that comes with being in an urban environment. I craved you.
So I came back, and for a while I got what I wanted. I lived on the border of Temescal and Rockridge, where I commuted to my waitressing job on a scooter. I could walk to Market Hall to pick up over-priced cheese and produce. On weekends we would drink lattes at Peaberry's sidewalk tables and watch the middle-aged yuppies push their babies around in strollers that cost more than my monthly rent. After getting drunk at the neighborhood pub I could stumble home to my studio cottage that was not much more than a converted garage. You and me, Oakland, we had a good thing going.
But then I grew up, got married, and realized I couldn't be a waitress for the rest of my life. I joined the rank and file and got a real job with steady paychecks, paid vacation and health insurance. When the real estate craze hit I was newly married with fantasies of laying down roots. Of course I wanted a piece of you, Oakland. I couldn't imagine buying a house anywhere else in the Bay Area. I wasn't going to be one of those people who go running for the suburbs when it was time to buy a house, robbing the cities of its tax base. I was not going to contribute to white flight, especially since I'm not white. You, Oakland, you had problems, but I was going to stick with you. I was going to make you better.
Flash forward to 2009. My husband and I have poured our money, our blood sweat and tears, our very heart and soul, into this house we bought 5 years ago. No, it's not in the Temescal or Rockridge. We couldn't afford those parts of you. Our home is in one of your modest working class neighborhoods near Mills College. Below *gasp* 580. I've done everything I can to be a positive influence on this neighborhood. I worked with my neighbors to petition the city for sidewalk trees. Flowering plums. Nine of them on my block. They're getting ready to bloom right now. I attended neighborhood watch meetings. I reached out to my neighbors. I tried to make you better, Oakland. But after 5 years it's clear that I'm not enough for you. All the people who love you and live within your borders aren't enough for you.
Oakland, you need professional help. You have this habit of sabotaging anything good that happens to you. You turn your back on those who love you most. You shit on the wonderful neighbors and homeowners in my neighborhood and beyond, the people who patronize your local business out of a sense of civic duty, the people who bought your properties at ridiculous prices and pay your crazy taxes without getting any services in return. You shit on us by robbing us, breaking into our houses, breaking into our cars, giving us dirty looks as we walk down the street as if we don't belong with you.
I'm tired of the way you treat me. I'm tired of your corruption, your bankrupt morals, your useless elected officials. I'm leaving you, but I know that deep down you will always be a part of me. I own a piece of you, which is basically like having your baby. I'm stuck with you until the kid turns 18, or until the market turns around and we can sell our house to the next set of idealistic urban warriors.
I may sound bitter, but I think in time it'll fade and turn bittersweet. As much pain as it's caused, this fling of ours has also brought me a lot of joy. It is an experience I will always treasure. I know you like the back of my hand and I will be back often to visit your Chinatown, your pho restaurants, and your taco trucks.
I truly wish with all my heart that someday you will get the help that you need to realize your full potential. I like to think I made a difference in your life as you did in mine. Maybe you're like an addict who just constantly needs people to believe in and support you. You'll always be an addict, and you'll burn through your supporters like you burned through me, but I can't help but hope that if we keep trying, if the busloads of idealistic and naive girls keep coming, someday you'll change your ways and become the city you were meant to be.